VCU Business students are first outside Harvard to study new case on fashion brand Ashley Stewart’s reinvention

VCU Business news

Students in a strategic management course discuss “Reimagining Ashley Stewart?” with James Rhee, the former investor and CEO at the center of the case.

Students in a classroom reading the Harvard Business Case.

Students at the Virginia Commonwealth University School of Business became the first students outside Harvard Business School to study “Reimagining Ashley Stewart?,” a new two-part case about the reinvention of the plus-size fashion brand Ashley Stewart.

The case, written by University Professor Rebecca Henderson, Ph.D., and independent researcher Jack Brookes, M.Div., draws heavily on "red helicopter―a parable for our times: lead change with kindness (plus a little math)," the 2024 national bestseller by James Rhee, Ashley Stewart’s former chairman and CEO. It asked VCU students to weigh a company’s financial statements against assets that conventional accounting does not capture, and business education often treats as secondary, like customer loyalty, employee commitment and the role its stores played in their communities.

It also brought into classroom discussion Rhee’s approach of leading with what he calls “kindness and math,” as he worked to rebuild trust with employees and vendors while the company ran out of cash.

“James threw himself into fixing the company in a way that many people would not have done,” said Henderson, who decided to write the case after meeting Rhee at a gathering of purpose-driven CEOs. She said the case shows the power of treating employees with dignity and respect and engaging them deeply in a company’s strategy and operations, an approach that has long interested her, but that it also “highlights the importance of personal commitment.”

Rhee led the discussion Sept. 9 in a strategic management class, during a daylong visit that helped launch the school’s Institute for Free Enterprise.

He began by asking students to define the company’s problem before deciding what to do about it, starting with what Ashley Stewart sold. He pushed them past the idea of a struggling apparel chain toward what he called the company’s “capital P Product,” the sense of belonging its stores gave customers, an asset that appeared nowhere on its financial statements.

“You need to know accounting, trust me, this is a language,” Rhee told students. “But you also have to understand it’s flawed.”

Bob Kelley, Ed.D., an assistant professor of practice who teaches the course, said his class had covered intangible assets the week before and asked whether private equity firms would ever learn to value assets like that. “The smart ones already know,” Rhee said, though he predicted many never would.

Sufiya Ahmed, a senior majoring in supply chain management, said she plans to carry the case’s lesson about what financial statements miss into a field built on costs and efficiency. “As I move forward in my career, I want to remember that doing my job well isn’t about achieving the best results on paper, but also considering the people affected by those decisions,” she said.

There were two ideas, Rhee said, that he wanted students to take from the case. The first was trust, which he described as the foundation of everything else. He said he earned it by telling employees the truth about the company’s finances and letting store managers teach him the business, and that the managers’ belief in him helped him trust himself.

The second was agency, the belief that a person can shape the future they want, which he called “the word that you really need to remember forever.”

For Rhee, the decision that ends the first part of the case was a test of agency. In late February 2014, Ashley Stewart was weeks from a bankruptcy filing likely to end in liquidation, and every investor Rhee approached had passed. He could ask a friend in private equity to back one last bid, committing himself to years of running the company, or let it go.

Ending at the moment of decision is central to the case method, which Harvard Business School’s first two deans championed almost a century ago, according to Walter Friedman, director of the school’s Business History Initiative. Students get only the information the decision maker had and must argue the choice without knowing how it turned out. Protagonists usually review a case before it is published, as Rhee did with this one, but rarely join the discussion.

Henderson said she put a question mark in the case’s title for the same reason. “I didn’t want to give the game away,” she said. “I wanted the students to really grapple with whether the company could be turned around.”

With Rhee in the room, the students heard the question from the person who faced it. “Would you have done it?” he asked.

“I think I would have stayed,” said Anna Nguyen, a senior majoring in information systems who grew up working at her mother’s nail shop and saw how much a small business could mean to its customers. Walking away, she said, would have been difficult “knowing that the business represented something meaningful to so many people.”

“James’ teaching approach was fantastic,” Kelley said. “I have had many outside speakers over the years, but never one that connected so well with my undergrads. It was pretty powerful to see.”

Henderson said the case does not depend on its protagonist being present. “While having James in the room is a delight, I have taught the case several times without him there, and it works almost as well,” she said. “It’s such a powerful story, and James’ commitment and energy is very apparent, even without him there.”

The second part of the case shows that Rhee made the call, that the company emerged from bankruptcy under new owners in 2014 and that it sold two years later for more than $140 million.

Rhee reminded the class that they would face choices of their own. “You don’t have the answer,” he said. “But you will have moments in time in your life, whether it’s business or not.” He described those decisions as moments of truth that come to define who a person is.

“Years from now, I may not remember every detail of the case, but I hope I remember how it challenged me to think differently about what makes a business successful,” Nguyen said.